ES&S Caught with Uncertified Machines in CA; Decertification May Result

Voting system certification is the formal process by which election equipment — from ballot scanners to electronic poll books to tabulation software — is tested against established technical standards before it can be legally used in an election. Certification typically happens at both the federal level, through standards maintained by the Election Assistance Commission, and at the state level, where individual states often layer additional requirements on top of federal certification before approving equipment for use within their borders.

Modifications to certified equipment — software updates, hardware changes, or configuration adjustments — generally have to go through their own review process before deployment, precisely because even a well-intentioned modification can alter how a system performs in ways that weren’t accounted for in its original certification testing. This is why compliance processes typically distinguish between the originally certified configuration of a system and any subsequent changes, requiring the changes themselves to be reviewed and approved rather than assuming the original certification automatically covers them.

When equipment is found to be operating with uncertified modifications, the consequences can range from required remediation and re-testing to, in more serious cases, decertification of the equipment for use in future elections until compliance is restored. States generally treat this kind of enforcement seriously, since the whole purpose of a certification regime is undermined if equipment can be modified after approval without any corresponding review.

For voters and election observers, understanding the certification and compliance process is useful context for evaluating any reported concern about voting equipment: the relevant question is usually not simply whether a piece of equipment works, but whether it’s operating in the exact configuration that was actually tested and approved. A robust compliance system, with real consequences for uncertified modifications, is one of the less visible but genuinely important safeguards in modern election administration.

The Broader Purpose of Certification Enforcement

Robust enforcement of voting equipment certification requirements serves a purpose beyond any single piece of equipment or any single jurisdiction. When states actively monitor for uncertified modifications and take meaningful corrective action when they’re found — rather than treating certification as a one-time formality — it sends a clear signal to vendors industry-wide that compliance is genuinely expected and enforced, not merely a box to check during initial approval. That signal shapes how vendors design update and deployment processes across their entire product line, not just for the specific jurisdiction where an issue was identified.

Balancing Necessary Updates and Certification Integrity

None of this means election equipment should never be updated after initial certification — software patches addressing genuine security vulnerabilities are sometimes necessary and beneficial. The key distinction is between updates that go through a proper re-certification or expedited review process, with documentation and independent verification, and undocumented changes that bypass that process entirely. States with clear, efficient pathways for reviewing legitimate necessary updates tend to see better vendor compliance than states where the re-certification process is so slow or burdensome that vendors are tempted to bypass it.